top of page
Image by NeONBRAND

Conestoga Title Insurance Underwriters

Our team of professional underwriting attorneys, agency and marketing representatives provide independent agents with the highest quality support and personal attention to help them achieve their business goals and objectives without competing against them.

Conestoga Title Insurance Company - 50 years in business celebration logo

Conestoga Title Insurance Co., celebrating fifty years in business, 

is a regional title insurance underwriter. Headquartered in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, we were founded in 1973, and offer comprehensive title insurance services through a network of highly qualified and experienced independent agents and approved attorneys. 


We are licensed to underwrite title insurance in: Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Indiana, Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi and the District of Columbia. Thank you for visiting our website.


Whether you’re an independent agent or an approved attorney seeking an underwriter, or a consumer in need of title insurance, we hope you find the information on our website helpful  - and we hope to earn your business. Thank you for visiting.


  • Agents from Pennsylvania, Virginia and Maryland recently gathered in Frederick, MD for a day of CE and CLE. Click Here to see more.

About Conestoga Title Insurance Co.

When we say we’re “There When it Matters Most,” we mean it. We’re one of the most trusted names in the title insurance underwriting industry.

Conestoga Title has provided reliable title insurance for the real estate, legal, and financial communities since 1973.


Our success is based on relationships, and our commitment to:


  • Service

  • Experience

  • Financial Security


Conestoga Title is a leader in the title industry, with an unprecedented dedication to training and agency support. We are committed to the expansion of our network of talented agents, and to providing them with the most effective and cutting-edge tools for success.


You’ll find our staff friendly, knowledgeable, and available, because we believe in the importance of excellent communication. Keeping our agents and clients informed of current events and legislation that can affect your business is a priority for Conestoga Title. 

Moving In

With the power of communication in mind, we provide:


After all, our skilled management team truly believes in the importance of being there for you, when it matters most. The success of a title company hinges upon the ability to build relationships, and the professional Conestoga Title Insurance team works hard to earn the respect of our title agents, clients and peers in the title insurance industry.  


Conestoga Title is a wholly owned subsidiary of Donegal Mutual Insurance Co., a mutual property and casualty insurance carrier. We hold  an “A Prime” rating from Demotech, Inc., designating us a company with “unsurpassed financial stability related to maintaining positive surplus… for policyholders,” regardless of any economic downturns or deterioration in the insurance cycle, no matter how severe.   

Our Title Agents

Conestoga Title Insurance provides independent title agents with the tools they need to be successful.

We’re dedicated to assisting agents with:

Prompt underwriting guidance
Personal agency support services
Consistent access to decision makers
Knowledgeable, available staff & personal attention

We’re committed to assisting you, our independent agents - not competing with you. Our business plan is focused on helping your bottom line - we never solicit realtors, lenders, builder customers, or our agents staff members.

Conestoga Title’s commitment to our independent agency network includes:

Exceptional customer service and competitive advantages for our agents

Guidance for establishing affiliated business arrangements and joint ventures

Employee on-site training

Title software integrations
Top-rated agency seminars & webinars with CE and CLE accreditation

Lower rate structures in PA for transactions $1M+

ALTA best practices resource center
Title search product

Contact Us to learn how we can help.

Agency Seminars

At Conestoga Title we have a long-standing tradition of providing continuing education for our title agents. From staying informed about relevant title industry topics to providing continuing education credits for title agents and continuing legal education credits for attorneys, we want you to be informed - and stay that way.


Attendance at our seminars and education programs is open to all agents and approved attorneys, regardless of their business relationship with our company. Attendees will gain valuable information and have the opportunity for networking with other title agents, attorneys and Conestoga's staff.


To learn more about our current title insurance seminars, click on the links by state to learn more.

bottom of page