top of page
Computer Keyboard

President's Message

Welcome to Conestoga Title Insurance Co.

On behalf of Conestoga Title Insurance Co., I would like to welcome you to our web site and thank you for your interest in our company.  Since 1973, we have served the needs of our policyholders by focusing on providing excellent customer service.  We have emerged as a strong and leading regional underwriter throughout the states in which we operate.

I encourage you to review the About Conestoga section of our web site to learn more about our company’s history, philosophy, mission statement, rating information, officers and parent company, Donegal Mutual Insurance Company.


For current agents, the Agent Extranet section provides online access for commitment, policy and closing protection letter generation. The Conestoga Newsletter section provides access to our quarterly publication which contains current and relevant title industry and company news. For those seeking employment in the title industry, please look for employment opportunities with us under the Contact Us section.

If you are considering an agency appointment with us, please refer to the Join Our Network section.  As an agent for our company, you will receive prompt, personalized service as well as direct access to decision-makers.  We are focused on providing independent agents with the tools needed to succeed.  Unlike many other underwriters, we are not focused on competing with our agents. Rather, we are dedicated to helping our agents thrive and grow their businesses.

Thank you once again for your interest in our company. I invite you to explore our web site and hope that you will consider us for your all of title insurance needs.


John M. Nikolaus, CLTP

bottom of page