top of page

50th Anniversary

Conestoga Title Insurance Co., a prominent regional title insurance underwriter headquartered in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, recently celebrated its 50th year in business.  Conestoga distinguishes itself by offering comprehensive title insurance services through a network of highly qualified and experienced independent agents and approved attorneys across Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia, Ohio, New Jersey and New York.  The company’s enduring success can be attributed to its commitment to the independent agency system.  Conestoga provides its agents with hands-on underwriting, operational and marketing support.


As the sole title insurer domiciled in Pennsylvania, Conestoga stands out for delivering prompt and expert service through its team of seasoned title professionals. Despite its relatively modest size, the company has invested in capabilities to compete effectively with larger, national title insurers.


John Nikolaus, President of Conestoga, expressed his gratitude, saying, "On behalf of our company, I am deeply honored to commemorate our remarkable 50-year journey in business. This milestone is a testament to the dedication and hard work of our exceptional employees, as well as the loyalty of our valued agents and policyholders. This celebration not only honors our rich history but also symbolizes the bright future that lies ahead, driven by our relentless commitment to excellence and innovation."

Conestoga is a wholly owned subsidiary of Donegal Mutual Insurance Co., a mutual property and casualty insurance carrier that serves as a valuable resource for the company.

50th Anniversary Press Release

bottom of page